Opinion: Why PCs, not smartphones, are best for social media sharing

Opinion: Why PCs, not smartphones, are best for social media sharing

In a world dominated by social media we must choose the best way to consume it


Part one of a two-part series. For a contrarian view, see "Why smartphones are the rightful kings of social media."

Walk anywhere within a 3-mile radius of the PCWorld office, and you'll find legions of new-economy hipsters with smartphones surgically implanted in their hands. But they're not talking on their phones. They're checking Facebook. They're posting to Twitter. They're making connections on LinkedIn. And a few of the more, well, eccentric souls may even be doing something on Google+.

But all these people are also making grave, grave mistakes. For, despite everything you've heard, the ultimate social media experience will never be found on a smartphone. No, it's waiting for you on your desktop PC.

Forget all the conventional wisdom about phones being tailor-made for social media consumption and broadcasting. Desk-bound computers are better--and not just because they protect us from posting inane real-time updates like "Eggs Benedict! Yum!" Our lives were not meant to be virtualized and crammed into the restrictive confinements of a little 4- or 5-inch screen. No, social media is best savored on a PC, where it's more productive, user-friendly, and fun.

Is this thing on?

Social media smartphone apps seems to be in perpetual beta--thus explaining why they crash so many times right in the middle of a critical maneuver. Granted, it's a first-world problem, but it's also a crappy user experience no matter how you cut it. If you run those same social media services on your desktop browser, however, you're much less likely to suffer the heartbreak of a mid-status-update disaster.

Desktop browser interfaces are generally more stable, and have near limitless memory to run their code. And this ensures not only that your social media experience continues uninterrupted, but that all your other fun activities continue apace. Mobile apps, meanwhile, are resource hogs and can drain what little memory and CPU cycles your smartphone has to offer. Scroll through that Facebook app, and everything begins to stutter--oftentimes taking down background tasks (music, navigation, a phone call) in the process.

But perhaps the biggest challenge to a good user experience is data delivery. Barring a freak broadband service outage, desktop PCs are always connected to the Internet. Your smartphone--not so much. It may be connected to Wi-Fi. It may be connected to 3G. You may have just posted something. Or maybe not. Sometimes you're online, but sometimes you're out of range.

The ugly side of social networking

Phones offer very little room for an expansive and clean user interface. Buttons are smothered for space, and there's just too much social networking to fit into those teeny, tiny screens. Indeed, when you only have enough room to see four tweets at a time, scrolling becomes a chore.

Even worse: Text entry. It's hard enough to compose a meaningful update that's worth sharing with the world. But when you have to cope with insanely small virtual keyboards and the frustrations of auto-correction, your tweets, Facebook posts, and other social media updates become time-consuming chores. Simply struggling to meet Twitter's character limit is enough to make you say, "Screw it. I'll save this thought until I can reach my PC."

Desktop browser interfaces, on the other hand, give us much more than a generous window for viewing ten-plus updates in a row, and much more than proper text entry driven by a full-scale, physical keyboard. They also expose the full set of tools, features and settings that social media services offer. Everything is available front and center, so you don't have to "page hop" to reach, say, your profile or security settings.

Be social, be productive

Social media services provide loud vocal cords for businesses, but trying to orchestrate content promotion on your smartphone is madness. To do it effectively, you need quick, comfortable access to tools for scheduling, account management, and analytics, and these are only available on the desktop, often through desktop client software.

Smartphones simply don't have the power or the screen real estate to handle these hefty tasks and to properly run a business's social media presence. Desktop clients like Tweetdeck help manage multiple Twitter streams in nice, organized columns, while SocialOomph, a browser-based service, lets you schedule updates, track keywords, and manage accounts for a variety of social media services. And let's not forget that Facebook's built-in post-scheduling feature isn't exposed in its own mobile apps.

Bottom line: Whether you use social media at work, or you're simply a hard-core power user, to truly master your social media universe, you'll need a PC.

Sharing is caring

Because sharing information--and funny cat videos--is the main function of any social network, it needs to be easy to do. And, thankfully, copying links, embedding videos, and uploading photos is all quick and easy with our handy mice and keyboards. The various sharing functions available in mobile operating systems and individual apps are supposed to make it easier to share content, but it's never as easy as sharing from the desktop.

Let's say you want to share a YouTube video on your Facebook feed. On the desktop, you simply copy the video's URL, drop it into your Facebook page, and post. On your iPhone, however, you must tap the video, tap the general sharing icon, tap the Share button that's spawned, tap the Facebook option, and then, finally, configure your Facebook account in the Settings menu. Tweeting that YouTube video wouldn't require the heinous configuration step, but it still requires way too many intermediary actions just to share.

And let's not forget that sharing rich content via your smartphone can be hazardous to both your wallet and your nerves. Spotty coverage means photos take forever to upload. Limited data plans mean those photos could end up costing you dearly. But neither issue is a problem when sharing big files via your PC.

Bad decisions are made mobile

The landline gave us drunk dialing. The cell phone supercharged the phenomenon by making it easier for the inebriated to call their ex-girlfriends or boyfriends from taverns and liquor-store parking lots. SMS messaging made the problem worse by allowing drunkards to send embarrassing photos to individual people. And now Facebook and Twitter let us share our lowest moments with, yikes... the entire world. (I won't mention any real-life cases here.)

Do you really want complete and immediate access to social media when your decision-making is at its most compromised? The flip side of instant communication is instant social suicide. But if your only access to social media is via your PC, at least you have to boot up, log in, and fire up your browser before tweeting or posting to Facebook. That may be just enough time to reconsider the wisdom of over-sharing your most, er, "human" moments.

Follow Us

Join the newsletter!


Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags social mediainternetsocial networkingInternet-based applications and servicesdesktop PC

Show Comments